Grand Rapids Churches Leave Christian Reformed Church Amid Disputes

News Summary

In a historic move, at least eight churches in Grand Rapids are set to leave the Christian Reformed Church (CRC) over disputes regarding LGBTQ inclusion and sexuality. This decision has sparked significant emotion within the community as congregations like Grace Church and Calvin Church aim to create more inclusive policies, allowing same-sex couples to marry and take on leadership roles. As the CRC enforces punitive measures against these disaffiliating churches, a broader trend of reevaluation among religious denominations is emerging.

Grand Rapids Churches at a Crossroads: Departure from Christian Reformed Church Sparks Emotion

Grand Rapids is witnessing a significant shift in its religious landscape, as at least eight churches in the area are gearing up to leave the Christian Reformed Church (CRC). This historic move comes on the heels of recent decisions made by the CRC regarding its stance on LGBTQ inclusion, particularly concerning same-sex relationships.

What Sparked the Split?

In 2022, the CRC clarified that its teachings on sexuality are of confessional status, making it a core part of the church’s belief system. This ruling indicated that churches, pastors, elders, and deacons are expected to align with the CRC’s conservative views on sexuality—or face potential disciplinary actions. This has only added fuel to the fire for churches like Grace Church, Calvin Church, and First Church, which are reevaluating their place within the CRC.

Taking a Stand

The disaffiliated churches are stepping away to honor their commitment to full inclusion. Their new policies permit same-sex couples to celebrate marriages, receive baptism, and even take on leadership roles within the church. This is a dramatic shift from the CRC’s teachings and showcases an effort to create a space where everyone feels welcomed and valued.

Grace Church took a decisive step back in December 2024 when it voted to disaffiliate, a choice that was not made lightly. Many congregants expressed feelings of pain and grief as they grappled with the implications of leaving a community they’ve been a part of for years. Similarly, Calvin Church initially hoped it could advocate for inclusion while remaining under the CRC umbrella, but the escalating circumstances led them to realize that their separation was inevitable.

The Reaction from the CRC

In response to these moves, the CRC has limited some disaffiliating churches under suspension for not adhering to its newly outlined policies regarding chastity and sexuality. This approach highlights the church’s commitment to preserving its traditional beliefs, even amid divisions among its members.

A Broader Trend

This disaffiliation is not an isolated incident but rather a reflection of a larger trend among various denominations grappling with issues of LGBTQ inclusion. The diminishing space for disagreement within the CRC has prompted congregations to reconsider their relationships with the church. With the general secretary of the CRC noting how little room there is for differing opinions anymore, many congregations are now exploring their post-disaffiliation options.

What Lies Ahead?

As several congregations make this critical transition, possibilities are opening up. Some may choose to become independent, while others might look to join more affirming denominations, like the Reformed Church in America or the United Church of Christ. The historic First Christian Reformed Church in Grand Rapids recently voted overwhelmingly, with a tally of 143-16, in favor of disaffiliation, a clear signal of the ongoing shifts in belief and community.

Emotional Goodbyes

The emotional toll of this situation is palpable, with both disaffiliating and remaining congregations feeling the weight of their decision. Deep connections have been forged over the years, and the sorrow stemming from separation runs deep. As of now, a total of 26 congregations have formally indicated their intent to disaffiliate from the CRC, and there are expectations that this number could increase as discussions continue.

Conclusion

Grand Rapids finds itself at a crossroads, as churches navigate through the complexities of faith, community, and inclusion. While some members look forward to a more inclusive future, others face the heart-wrenching reality of leaving behind a church they’ve cherished. The unfolding story of these congregations is not just about a split—it’s about love, acceptance, and finding the right path forward in a changing world.

Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic

HERE Resources

West Michigan Gears Up for Lent with Fish Fry Events
Lansing Discusses Same-Sex Marriage Rights Controversy
Grand Rapids Schools Respond to Immigration Policy Changes

Additional Resources

• MLive: What’s going on off 28th Street?
• Fox17: Grand Rapids churches leaving the CRC over sexuality
• MinistryWatch: Christian Reformed Church losing ministers over LGBTQ stance
• Google Search: LGBTQ Inclusion in Church
• Fulcrum7: 33 congregations leave Christian Reformed Church to accept LGBTQ ideology
• Encyclopedia Britannica: Christian Reformed Church